One of the major differences between the movie and homer's epic poem is that the iliad ends with the funeral of hector, whereas the movie goes on to portray other events (eg, the wooden horse. In conclusion, although the iliad is based upon troy, it is not really fair to compare the two a book and a movie are two entirely different things it is almost like comparing apples to oranges. Smellin' of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the big-budget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history this list was provided by dr james holoka , professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that (despite this list) he did enjoy the movie. Comparison between the iliad and the women of troy essay - the iliad by homer and the women of troy by euripides are both greek works of literature that look at the trojan war from different perspectives.
Compare and contrast the movie troy with iliad contrasts of troy and the iliad troy and the iliad are very similar in the story line and the all-around theme but there are huge fundamental changes the director made to the story to increase the likeability of the movie. In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy briseis is a trojan priestess and hector's cousin, captured during the attack on apollo's temple. Agamemnon used helen as an excuse to attack troy & troy's real motives were power and money the similarities: part two the greeks won the war, and the trojan horse let them win the differences: part one the war lasted 10 years the differences: part two troy the similarities: part three the trojan war started because paris took helen. The producer of the movie troy, did a very good job of making it similar to the book the iliad but there were some differences in it, as well the gods played a role in the book and they determined who was going to live or die or which side was going to win or lose.
Achilles and hector as contrasting heroes in the iliad achilles and hector are both great warriors for their armies achilles commands the greek army, while hector commands the trojan army. The film's credits make clear that troy was 'inspired by' homer's the iliad this informs our experience of the film, and it contains a lot of events that homer never wrote about. Homers poem the iliad is an epic poem that describes the majority of the war between greek and trojan the purpose of this essay is to enhance our critical reading and writing skills the mean of this is essay is compare and contrast between achilles and hector discussing the similarities. Troy and the iliad compare and contrast essays existentialism in film essays on the great my dissertation journey essay activity essayez et vous verrez.
Troy movie and illiad compare and contrast essay in english class we read edith hamilton's synopsis of the trojan war, and after reading, we watched the warner brothers 2004 production of troy the movie and the myth were both based on the trojan war. Best answer: the illiad is a book about the battle of troy with achillies and hector and all that but helen of troy is about a slutty queen that left her husband for paris,the prince of troy. The film troy is a movie released in 2004 and was directed by wolfgang petersen, and has been influenced by the classical epic poem, the iliad which has been credited of the greek poet homer both texts deal with the same subject, the siege of troy which was ended with the trickery of the wooden horse.
In both the iliad and troy, when achilles defeats and kills hector in battle, he proceeds to tie hector's body to his chariot, and to the horror of priam (hector's father), he proceeds to drag hector's body around the outskirts of troy, dirtying and mutilating the corpse. In the movie troy, the characters such as achilles, agamemnon are presented in the same way as they are presented in the epic the plot is also similar to the iliad on the other hand, there are significant differences between the movie and the epic. Troy vs iliad a comparsion between the epic poem the iliad and the modern film troy the film troy is a movie released in 2004 and was directed by wolfgang petersen, and has been influenced by the classical epic poem, the iliad which has been credited of the greek poet homer. Analysis between the movie troy and the book the iliad troy was a very impressive and solid movie, which would surely leave a lasting impression on people the movie definitely made many changes from the poem the iliad.
The reason for the differences in the film troy from the iliad are mostly for the sake of convenience to the director and for entertainment, however the film was relatively censored compared to the poem, which was very graphic in the portrayal of violence. Contrasts of troy and the iliad troy and the iliad are very similar in the story line and the all-around theme but there are huge fundamental changes the director made to the story to increase the likeability of the movie. Troy vs homers iliad (a comparison between the two with a mix of movie reviewing) by amber shepherd when comparing the movie troy, directed by wolfgang petterson, and the iliad, written by greek poet homer we can clearly see that although petterson has made an excellent film he has clearly left out certain aspects of the iliad which really define the story.
Troy vs homers iliad (a comparison between the two with a mix of movie reviewing) by amber shepherd when comparing the movie troy, directed by wolfgang petterson, and the iliad, written by greek poet homer we can clearly see that although petterson has made an excellent film he has clearly left out certain aspects of the iliad which really. A few key themes are shown in both the film troy and the poem, the iliad in troy the main themes that are shown are the themes, love and the idea that death is glory in the poem, the iliad, the major theme that is shown is the greek concept of kleos.
Dicuss similarities and differences between homer's iliad and the movie troy essay sample the ancient legend of troy, recorded in homer's epic poem the iliad oxford (trans robert fitzgerald university press 1974) has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy (2004, wolfgang peterson. Get an answer for 'what can my thesis statemnet be for comparing the film troy and the actual mythology of the trojan war as seen in the iliad' and find homework help for other essay lab. Comparison paper on the book iliad and film troy on the plot the plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus the coverage of the film starts all the way from why the trojan-greeks conflict started up to the death of achilles and the fall of troy. Analysis and comparison-character-achilles by ktmsbhs achilles is one of the most famous warriors to have ever lived and was the most skillful warrior in the trojan war which homer's iliad and wolfgang peterson's troy is based around.